Hey there,
A SaaS founder showed me their homepage last week.
"We're 10x better than [competitor]," he said.
I looked at the website. No mention of that competitor. No comparison. No switching guide.
"Why doesn't your marketing say this?"
"Our investor said never mention competitors. Makes us look desperate."
Meanwhile, 60% of their prospects are already using that competitor.
And those prospects have no idea why they should switch.
The Real Problem
Most of your prospects aren't starting from zero. They're already using a competitor.
But your marketing acts like:
You're the only option in the market
They're making a fresh decision
Comparing features is enough
The reality:
They have a current solution (even if it's broken)
Switching costs time, money, and political capital
They need a reason compelling enough to justify the pain of change
When you ignore the competitor they're currently using, you ignore the biggest objection in their head:
"Is this worth the hassle of switching?"
The Pepsi Lesson (Done Right)
Everyone thinks Pepsi tried to "beat" Coca-Cola head-on.
They didn't. They got smarter.
What Coca-Cola owned:
Tradition ("The Real Thing")
Nostalgia (Santa Claus, classic Americana)
Older demographic
"This is what my parents drank"
What Pepsi did: They didn't say "We're better than Coke."
They said: "Pepsi is for the next generation."
The Pepsi Generation campaign positioned them as:
Young and modern (vs. Coke's traditional)
Bold and rebellious (vs. Coke's safe)
Forward-thinking (vs. Coke's nostalgia)
The genius: They didn't try to replace Coca-Cola with everyone. They targeted a different audience with the same product category.
Coke = Your parents' choice
Pepsi = Your generation's choice
Same product (cola). Different positioning. Different target.
The result: Pepsi didn't need to be "better." They just needed to be "different for a specific group."
This is what most B2B companies miss.
How to Position Against a Competitor (Without Looking Desperate)
You don't need to bash your competitor. You need to show who you're for and why that matters for someone currently using them.
Strategy 1: Target a Different Segment (The Pepsi Play)
Don't say: "We're better than [Competitor]"
Say: "We're built specifically for [segment] that [Competitor] doesn't serve well"
Example - Notion vs. Confluence:
Confluence positioning: Enterprise wiki and documentation
Notion positioning: "The workspace for small, fast-moving teams who don't want enterprise complexity"
What this does:
Doesn't attack Confluence directly
Makes it clear who it's NOT for (enterprises)
Makes it clear who it IS for (small teams tired of complexity)
The switching message: "If Confluence feels like overkill, you're not the problem. You're just not their target anymore."
Strategy 2: Acknowledge the Incumbent, Position the Shift
Don't ignore: That they're using a competitor Acknowledge it: "Switching from [Competitor]? Here's what's different"
Example - Superhuman vs. Gmail:
Superhuman doesn't pretend Gmail doesn't exist. Their positioning:
"For professionals who live in email and need to get through it 2x faster"
Their website literally has: "Switching from Gmail?" with a migration guide.
What this does:
Validates that Gmail is fine for most people
Positions Superhuman for a specific need (speed for heavy users)
Removes friction by addressing switching directly
Strategy 3: Own a Specific Belief the Incumbent Doesn't
Don't say: "We have more features"
Say: "We believe [X] should work differently. Here's why."
Example - Basecamp vs. Asana/Monday:
Asana/Monday belief: More features, more customization, more power
Basecamp belief: "Software should be calm, not overwhelming"
Basecamp's positioning: "Project management for teams who hate project management software"
What this does:
Takes a stand on what's broken (complexity)
Attracts people frustrated with feature-bloat
Repels people who want maximum customization (and that's okay)
The switching message: "Tired of tools that require training manuals? Us too."
The Switching Content You're Missing
Here's what stops people from switching (even when your product is better):
Objection 1: "What happens to our data?"
Missing content: Data migration guide, export/import walkthrough
Objection 2: "How long does it take to set up?"
Missing content: "From [Competitor] to us in 48 hours" implementation timeline
Objection 3: "What if my team hates it?"
Missing content: "How 3 teams successfully switched without disruption" case studies
Objection 4: "What if we lose something important?"
Missing content: Feature comparison that shows what you have that they don't (and what they have that you don't, be honest)
Objection 5: "Is this worth the political battle internally?"
Missing content: ROI calculator showing cost of staying vs. switching
Most B2B websites have NONE of this content.
Then they wonder why warm leads go cold during evaluation.
Real Example
Before (pretending competitor doesn't exist):
Homepage: "Modern project management for growing teams"
Features page: List of capabilities
Pricing page: Plans and pricing
Case studies: Generic success stories
No mention of: The competitor 70% of prospects are currently using Conversion rate: 1.8% (mostly net-new market)
Sales objection: "How is this different from [Competitor] we're already paying for?"
After (acknowledging the switching reality):
Homepage: "Project management for teams outgrowing [Competitor]"
New page: "Switching from [Competitor]? Here's what changes (and what stays the same)" New content:
Migration guide (what happens to your data)
"Why teams switch" (specific pain points with competitor)
Side-by-side comparison (honest about trade-offs)
Timeline: "Most teams are fully migrated in 5 days"
Conversion rate: 3.1% (now converting replacement buyers, not just new market) Sales feedback: "Prospects come in already understanding the difference"
The difference: Stopped pretending the competitor doesn't exist. Started helping people make the switch.
Your Action Item This Week
Step 1: Identify your real competitor
Not "who do we compete with in theory." Ask: "Who are our last 10 customers replacing or switching from?"
That's your real competition.
Step 2: Audit for switching content
Do you have ANY content that:
Mentions that competitor by name?
Addresses how to switch?
Explains what happens to existing data/workflows?
Shows timeline from their tool to yours?
If the answer is no, that's why your qualified leads aren't converting.
Step 3: Create ONE piece of switching content
Pick the #1 competitor you're replacing.
Create: "Switching from [Competitor] to [You]: What to expect"
Include:
Why teams make the switch (specific pain points)
What happens to their data
How long it takes
What they gain (and what trade-offs exist)
The test: Send it to your sales team. Ask: "Would this answer the questions prospects have?"
If yes, publish it. Watch your conversion rate climb.
That's it for this week.
Next issue: Your marketing says "We're better." Your prospect thinks "But switching is risky."
